Here at Organic Wine Journal we’ve had a number of winemakers argue for listing the full ingredients on the back label of a wine bottle (you didn’t think it was just grapes, did you?). A recent piece in the New York Times addresses the issue:
What if the label actually listed the ingredients? There might not be room for them all. Well, maybe on a magnum.
No, wine isn’t just fermented grape juice. The European Union permits 59 things to be added to it, some of them seemingly innocuous (water), others icky (“lactic bacteria,” “edible gelatine”), still others downright scary-sounding (“ferrous sulfate,” “polyvinylpolypyrrolidone”). The United States permits many of these things, plus a few dozen more.
Yet unlike makers of, say, yogurt or soft drinks, winemakers are required to disclose only one additive, sulfur dioxide, via that nearly ubiquitous footnote that reads, “contains sulfites.”
At a time when consumers are demanding more transparency about the things they eat and drink, there is still a distinct lack of veritas in vino. Unless you have an unusually sophisticated palate — “I’m getting hints of betaglucanese here, with a note of potassium ferrocyanide, followed by a nice touch of urease on the finish” — it can be difficult to tell what’s actually in the wine.
Over at Eater.com our friend Talia Baiocchi interviewed people from all sides of the wine business to ask what affect this would have:
Greg Harrington MS | Founder & Winemaker, Gramercy Cellars, Walla Walla
Are you for or against listing the ingredients added in the production of wine on a bottle’s back label?
I don’t have a problem listing ingredients, but I am positive there will be misconceptions about the ingredients. At Gramercy we use cultured yeasts, malolactic bacteria, nutrients (such as nitrogen) and vitamins for fermentation. Sulfur is used for stabilization. The regiment is designed to ensure clean and strong first and secondary fermentations and to protect the wine as it ages. I do think many wineries are afraid of the perception of the long list of additives they would have to list on the label. Is it wrong to use these additives? I could absolutely debate it both ways. But what is the goal: A more natural wine or a better tasting wine?